Oct 10, 2013

Critical Response to TM Article

The following excerpts are taken from letters to the editor of the Journal of the American Medical Association responding to "Letter from New Delhi -- Maharishi Ayur-Veda: modern insights into ancient medicine" (JAMA, 1991; 265:2633-2634, 2637). The letters appeared in JAMA, 1991; 266(Oct. 2): 1769-1773.

Useful Information
Maharishi Ayur-Veda stands out as having a coherent and easy-to-understand philosophy, and it is backed up by rigorous scientific research. . .  I hope we can look forward to more of this kind of information being published in the leading journals.

Michael T. Greenwood, M.B., B.Ch., Victoria, British Columbia (Dr. Greenwood reports using Maharishi Ayur-Veda in his practice.)


As a board-certified neurologist, I have found that my training in Maharishi Ayur-Veda has been absolutely invaluable in dealing with those problems typical to this specialty.

David Pearlmutter, M.D., Naples, FL. (Dr. Pearlmutter reports that he is an Ayur-Vedic physician.)


Just as quantum mechanics was incorporated into physics, it is time for medicine to transcend classical mechanics and to investigate the benefits of quantum field-based health maintenance.

Steele Belok, M.D., Harvard Medical School, Boston. MA.

A Religion
The article . . . does not belong in JAMA. . . I am frightened that JAMA would print , and thus give credibility to magic, astrology, rituals, and potions for the prevention and cure of disease. . .  [The authors] are followers of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. [They] are "converts" to his religious system. . . By failing to cite the contraindications/problems with headaches, insomnia, concentration, gastrointestinal upset, hallucinations, anxiety, depression, and destruction of personality of Maharishi Ayur-Veda, the authors violate the ethics of informed consent.

Patrick L. Ryan, Philadelphia, PA.
(Mr. Ryan is a former TM member who speaks publicly against the organization as an educational consultant.)

Hocus-Pocus
I recommend that you follow "Maharishi Ayur-Veda: Modern Insights into Ancient Medicine" with republication of "The Emperor's New Clothes." The use of the word "ancient" in the title is the key: the ideas expressed were pure hocus-pocus and truly ancient ignorance. Pathetic.

Gary Gorlock, M.D., M.P.H., Los Angeles

A Destructive Cult
As president of the American Family Foundation [publisher of the Cult Observer], an organization of professionals including lawyers, psychiatrists, and psychologists, as well as religious leaders dedicated to educating the public about the dangers of destructive cults, I am appalled that this letter [on TM] found its way into your journal. Clearly, this letter is part of a carefully orchestrated and well-financed plan by the TM movement to obtain credibility and acceptance in our society for its unscientific jargon and religious rituals.

Lending your journal to a campaign of this kind seriously exposes you to legal liability for those who might rely on your reputation and follow the described advice and practices. . .

Herbert L. Rosedale, Esq., Weston, MA.

I have been working in the field of destructive cults for 20 years and have concluded that the TM movement is a dangerous cult, damaging both physically and, especially, psychologically to its followers.

Marcia R. Rudin, M.A. (Ms. Rudin is director of the International Cult Education Program [and a member of the editorial board of the Cult Observer].)

A Recruitment Enterprise
[The letter] is a subtle attempt to recruit new followers into the TM movement. . . The Maharishi, referred to as "His Holiness" by his followers, aggressively markets his brand of meditation, TM, as a health benefit to improve quality of life. In fact, the meditation instruction is a front for a missionary enterprise, encouraging students to meditate for large parts of the day, along with increasing participation in a form of demythologized Hinduism. This conversion is done by the gently titrating exposure of TM devotees to Hindu philosophy and practice, without initially defining them as such.

    . . .  Many Jews and Christians with limited knowledge of their own heritage are misled by TM to believe that their new activities and beliefs are not incompatible with the religion of their births. . . those on spiritual quests should be aware that meditation practices are found within Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions, and also in a true secular format via contemporary psychology.

John Hochman, M.D. , Los Angeles [Dr. Hochman is a member of an advisory committee of the American Family Foundation, publisher of the Cult Observer.]

School for Abuse
My work has provided a disturbing view of wife abuse, violence against children, health abuse, and a total disregard for the psychological horrors that TM techniques foster and justify. The causes of these practices are, like TM Ayur-Veda medicine, woven together by TM's strain of Hindu mythology. . . The medical program of TM, based as it is on TM's notoriously suspect "research," is a form of "mind over matter" magic. . . . [The letter's description of the mind, for example] as "a physical expression of the self-interacting dynamics of an underlying abstract field of intelligence" . . . is a reference to Hinduism's concept of Maya (matter is an illusion), Maya's integral relation to Monism (all things are made of one substance), and the belief that this substance is spirit. Transcendental Meditation defies all medical knowledge because it accepts the archaic belief that disease is the result of assault by female demons! This bit of truth, of course, is not acknowledged to Western audiences. If a method's veracity and effectiveness should be tested before being recommended and applied, then your readers have the benefit of over 2000 years of de facto research. The laboratory is India itself - chaos, epidemics, caste-dominated cruelty, and bizarre superstitions reign. This - rather than a pristine world of joy, health, and serenity - is what TM breeds.

Kevin Garvey, Hamden, CT.
(Mr. Garvey is a paid consultant on TM activities for attorneys [and a member of advisory committees of the American Family Foundation, publisher of the Cult Observer].)

Cultic
According to TM-EX, TM uses deceptive recruiting practices and the organization's rules and regulations are presented to members as being absolute. A new vocabulary is taught to recruits to explain ordinary phenomena, and the group uses undue influence techniques of mind control, guilt, and phobia induction to maintain membership. . . JAMA should have looked into this movement a bit more before giving it such a bold place in our premier medical journal.

Ralph Smith, Jr., M.D., Charleston. WV.
[Dr. Smith is a member of an advisory committee of the American Family Foundation, publisher of the Cult Observer.]

Cult Observer, Volume 8, Number 10, 1991

Presentations by Patrick Ryan (1990-1999)


May 1991, Philadelphia, PA

1992 Annual Conference of the American Family Foundation
May 8-9, 1992, Arlington, VA

Cult Victims and Their Families: Therapeutic Issues
Annual Conference of the American Family Foundation
May 8-9, 1992, Arlington, VA

After the Cult
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
May 21-22, 1992, Stony Point, NY

Coping with Trance States; Hypnosis and Trance
After the Cult
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
May 21-22, 1993, Stony Point, NY

Cult Awareness Network
April 17, 1994, Newark,NJ

Coping with Trance States; Hypnosis and Trance
After the Cult
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
June 2-4, 1995, Stony Point, NY

Workshop for Loved Ones: "How to Help a Loved One Affected by a Cult"
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
June 7-9, 1996, Stony Point, NY

Exit Counseling
Conference Women and Cults: Psychological Manipulation: The Abuse of Women
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
May 30-31, 1997, Philadelphia, PA

Panel: From Deprogramming to Thought Reform Consultation
Carol Giambalvo; Patrick Ryan; Hana Whitfield; Joseph Kelly
1998 Jonestown Memorial Conference, 20 Years After Jonestown: What Have We Learned About Cults
November 13-15, 1998, Chicago, IL

When People Ask About Cults: Secular and Evangelical Responses Craig Bran;Carol Giambalvo; Patrick Ryan; Marty Butz, M.Div.; Paul Carden; Moderator; Dr. Michael  Langone
1998 Jonestown Memorial Conference, 20 Years After Jonestown: What Have We Learned About Cults
November 13-15, 1998, Chicago, IL

Family Workshop
Livia Bardin; Patrick Ryan; Hana Whitfield
1998 Jonestown Memorial Conference, 20 Years After Jonestown: What Have We Learned About Cults
November 13-15, 1998, Chicago, IL

Educators Workshop
Patrick Ryan
1998 Jonestown Memorial Conference, 20 Years After Jonestown: What Have We Learned About Cults
November 13-15, 1998, Chicago, IL

Thought Reform Consultation (Exit Counseling): Helping Families Address a Loved One’s Group Involvement
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
"Children and Cults" Conference
May 29-31, 1998, Philadelphia, PA

Workshop for former members of cultic groups
Patrick Ryan; Joseph Kelly
November 19–21, 1999, Stony Point, NY

Coping with Trance States; Hypnosis and Trance

Symposium: So You Want to Help: What Can Individuals D?Sandy Andron, Ed.D.; Patrick Ryan; Heather Svoboda
1999 Conference: Cults, Psychological Manipulation & Society
May 14-16, 1999, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN

Symposium: So You Want to Help: What Can Individuals D?Sandy Andron, Ed.D.; Patrick Ryan; Heather Svoboda
1999 Conference: Cults, Psychological Manipulation & Society
May 14-16, 1999, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN

Educators Workshop
Sandy Andron, Ed.D.; Michael Langone, Ph.D.; Marcia Rudin; Patrick Ryan
1999 Conference: Cults, Psychological Manipulation & Society
May 14-16, 1999, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN

Thought Reform Consultation: A Panel Discussion
David Clark; Carol Giambalvo; Joseph Kelly; Patrick Ryan; Hana Whitfield; Jerry Whitfield; Mike Kropveld, Moderator
1999 Conference: Cults, Psychological Manipulation & Society
May 14-16, 1999, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN

Presentations by Patrick Ryan (2000+)

Thought Reform Consultants

A number of experts experienced in thought reform counseling have become informally associated in an Internet-based "Thought Reform News." The group's initial statement says that "Consultation refers to a voluntary relationship between a professional helper and help-needing individual, family, group, or social unit in which the consultant is providing information that enables client(s) to more clearly define and solve the problem(s) for which they sought consultation." 

"Thought reform consultation is the presentation of information concerning the principles and practical applications of thought reform. 

This presentation is done in a manner that is legal and conforms to a set of ethical standards. The consultation involves a respectful dialogue in an open environment, supplemented by educational materials, such as pertinent literature, generic source materials, informational multimedia presentations, and personal testimonies. 

A thought reform consultant is an individual who conducts these consultations and voluntarily agrees to abide by a set of ethical standards." 

The consultants associated in the "Thought Reform Consultants News" include Carol Giambalvo, Janja Lalich, Patrick Ryan, Joseph Kelly, Joseph Szimhart, and Jerry and Hana Whitfield. [The first three are associates and advisors of AFF, publisher of The Cult Observer.] (Cult Observer report)   

Patrick Ryan Profile

Patrick Ryan, a graduate of Maharishi International University (focus in eastern philosophy) former Associate teacher  of Transcendental Meditation, has been a cult intervention specialist (thought reform consultant/exit counselor,mediator) since 1984.


Mr. Ryan is the founder and former head of TM-EX, the organization of ex-members of Transcendental Meditation.  He established ICSA's online resource (1995-2013), was the editor of AFF News, a news publication for former cult members (1995-1998), has contributed to the Cult Observer,  AFF’s book, Recovery From Cults, is co-author of "Ethical Standards for Thought Reform Consultants," and has presented 50 programs about hypnosis, inner-experience, trance-induction techniques, communicating with cult members, conversion, cult intervention, exit counseling, intervention assessment, mediation, religious conflict resolution, thought reform consultation, eastern groups, transcendental meditation and workshops for educators, families, former members and mental health professionals at ICSA workshops/conferences. Mr. Ryan received the AFF Achievement Award (1997) from AFF, the Leo J. Ryan "Distinguished Service Award" (1999) from the Leo J. Ryan Foundation, and a Lifetime Achievement Award (2011) from ICSA.


Mr. Ryan has also facilitated ICSA workshops for ex-members and families (1996-2018) and has  lectured extensively on cult-related topics:


  • Some of the topics: 
    • Inner Experience and Conversion
    • After the Cult "Coping with Trance States; Hypnosis and Trance" 
    • Coping with Triggers
    • Mental-Health Issues in Cult-Related Interventions
    • Leaving and Recovering from Cultic Groups and Relationships
    • Communicating with Cult Members
    • Restoring Family Connections
    • Helping Families Address a Loved One’s Group Involvement
    • Among the issues discussed are:
      • The ethics of an intervention
      • Assessing a family situation
      • Determining whether an intervention is appropriate
      • Family preparation
      • The phases and dynamics of an intervention
      • Alternatives to interventions
      • Issues confronted after an intervention
      • Workshop for Loved Ones: "How to Help a Loved One Affected by a Cult" 
    • What Can Families Do? Family members concerned about a loved one‘s cult involvement or its aftereffects need to learn how to assess their situations more effectively and how to evaluate strategic options. 
    • A Mediation Approach to Exit Counseling 
    • From Deprogramming to Thought Reform Consultation 
    • Can Cultic Groups Change? The Case of ISKCON 
    • Evolution and Variation Within a Movement: The Case of ISKCON 
    • Jehovah’s Witnesses, Former Members and Families 
    • "Cultic Group Intervention: Exploring internal experiences in Yoga, Qigong and Transcendental Meditation" 
    • Inside Out — One Group, One Fugitive Swami: Three Different Experiences 
    Lectures/workshops - Universities, Countries 
    • 1999, University of Minnesota, St. Paul, MN
    • 2004, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta (Canada)
    • 2005, Universidad Autonoma de Madrid, Madrid, (Spain)
    • 2007, University Club, Brussels, (Belgium) 
    • 2008, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 
    • 2009, Geneva, Switzerland 
    • 2010, Istituto Madonna del Carmine “Il Carmelo”, Ciampino, Roma, (Italy) 
    • 2011, University of Barcelona, Barcelona, (Spain)
    • 2012, Montreal, Canada
    • 2013, London School of Economics 
    • 2014 University of Southern California 
    • 2015, Stockholm, Sweden
    • 2015, Beijing Union University, Beijing, China 
    • 2017, Bordeaux France


Maharishi Ayur-Veda

Patrick L. Ryan JAMA. 1991;266(13):1770. doi:10.1001/jama.1991.03470130045016

To the Editor.  —The article regarding Maharishi Ayur-Veda1 does not belong in JAMA.To print a journal article that is read by thousands of medical doctors promoting hocus-pocus medicine is unconscionable. The German government has issued public warnings concerning aspects of Maharishi Ayur-Veda.2 I am frightened that JAMA would print, and thus give credibility to magic, astrology, rituals, and potions for the prevention and cure of disease.The article has factual errors and, by omission, paints a false picture of a rather unscrupulous organization. Most references cited are generated by the Transcendental Meditation (TM) "movement." Professional critiques of TM research state that "the scientific research is without objectivity, and at times, simply untrue," and it is "deliberately contrived to mislead the public." Thus, the approach is: if you don't believe us, ask us.Drs Chopra and Sharma are followers of Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. The authors are "converts"3

Contact Patrick Ryan

Patrick Ryan
Philadelphia, PA